Juan Soto opened the scoring with a two-run homer in the third. Texas answered in the fifth: Jake Burger singled home Brandon Nimmo, and Evan Carter's force out brought Burger around to tie it 2-2. Rangers starter Cody Bradford lasted 4 1/3 innings and allowed the two early runs. Nolan McLean kept the Mets in the game with seven innings of two-run, four-hit pitching and five strikeouts.
The decisive swing came in the eighth. Semien hit his 15th homer, a solo shot off Jacob Latz, to break the tie against the club he previously played for. The Associated Press and MLB's game log agree on the sequence. MLB's official game video shows the homer and the later ninth-inning blow. MLB's official September 23 full-game highlights show the key plays from this matchup.