Creel finished 26 of 44 for 311 passing yards, one touchdown and one interception. He also scored on a two-yard run in the second quarter. Deondre Johnson supplied four catches for 112 yards, while Likely led the Gamecocks with 40 rushing yards and a touchdown. The passing game carried an offense that finished with only 74 yards on the ground.
Collins completed 24 of 34 passes for 293 yards and a touchdown, added 61 rushing yards and a score, and threw two interceptions. Munroe caught seven passes for 159 yards. Kennesaw State outgained Jacksonville State 410–385, but the final interception denied it the chance to turn that yardage edge into another late scoring opportunity.
Both teams committed two turnovers. Penalties also took a substantial toll: Kennesaw State was charged with 15 for 137 yards, Jacksonville State with 11 for 93. On the winning drive, the defensive holding call gave the Gamecocks a fresh set of downs when they needed it most. Rippa and Billings then finished the two possessions that decided the night.