Tampa Bay's first run came without a hit driving it home. Yandy Díaz opened the game with a double, and the Rays eventually loaded the bases before Jonny DeLuca drew a two-out walk from Parker Messick. The free pass brought Díaz home for a 1-0 lead.
Jonathan Aranda singled in Ben Williamson in the second inning. Chandler Simpson then doubled in the third, stole third base and scored on Liam Hicks's single to center. The Rays had a 3-0 advantage without hitting a home run.
That early work forced Cleveland to use its bullpen sooner than planned. Messick lasted two innings, allowing two runs and five hits while throwing 57 pitches. Tim Herrin surrendered Tampa Bay's third run after taking over in the third.
Cleveland finally reached Rasmussen in the sixth. Steven Kwan and José Ramírez singled, and Chase DeLauter's groundout brought Kwan home. Rasmussen prevented any further scoring, then finished his outing with a scoreless seventh that ended on Patrick Bailey's double play.
The Rays used three relievers to cover the final two innings. Cam Booser got the first two outs of the eighth, and Tyler Wells struck out Ramírez to strand a runner. Bryan Baker worked the ninth for his fifth save of the postseason, ending the game on Travis Bazzana's groundout.