James Madison's official report credited cornerback DJ Kelly with two interceptions. One helped set up Pettaway's second touchdown. Marshall's starting and reserve quarterbacks each threw one interception, while Coleman finished without one. The Dukes committed a fumble, but Marshall turned that opportunity into only a third-quarter field goal.
Del Rio-Wilson completed 21 of 37 passes for 221 yards and a touchdown. Zion Turner added 88 passing yards. Marshall totaled 444 yards and made eight of 16 third downs, numbers that show it could move the ball without keeping pace on the scoreboard. Its rushing game produced 135 yards, led by Jo'Shon Barbie's 44.
James Madison allowed only three points after halftime. Nick Herman supplied the second half's only touchdown, finishing an 80-yard drive with a three-yard run in the final minute. The Dukes had already done the scoring work that mattered before the break, when they accumulated 387 yards according to the school report.
The result improved James Madison to 5–0 overall and 2–0 in the Sun Belt, while Marshall fell to 3–2 and 0–1. The Dukes travel to Georgia Southern next Saturday. With Coleman finding Scott early and Pettaway turning ordinary possessions into long touchdowns, James Madison recovered from two early Marshall leads and gave its defense a 24-point halftime cushion to protect.