The Wolverines started Tommy Carr over Bryce Underwood, a week after Carr came off the bench in a win over Penn State. Carr was sacked on the drive that reached the 1, and the series ended with a missed 32-yard field goal, according to the Associated Press. In the last minute of regulation Michigan reached the 3, Carr took his fourth sack, and Trey Butkowski kicked a 26-yarder as time ran out just to get to overtime. Butkowski finished 2 for 4.
Indiana's offense wasn't much better. Josh Hoover went 8 of 18 for 81 yards with an interception, and Curt Cignetti said Hoover isn't completely healthy. But on the first play of overtime Hoover hit Brock Schott for 21 yards, and he ran it in from the 4 soon after.
Michigan then drove to the Indiana 13 needing a touchdown. Carr's last throw hit the ground in front of Salesi Moa just outside the end zone.