Cleveland's final rally began with DeLauter's single and continued through two walks. Nathaniel Lowe, who entered as a pinch hitter, lifted a sacrifice fly to left against Erik Miller, bringing DeLauter home. Cade Smith closed the game for Cleveland with a scoreless ninth and earned his save after Hunter Gaddis recorded the win.
Tolle worked 5 2/3 innings for Boston, allowing two runs on eight hits with five strikeouts and two walks. Cleveland starter Parker Messick held Boston to one run over five innings, and the Guardians' bullpen allowed only one run across the final four innings. Boston's offense produced eight hits but went 0-for-7 with runners in scoring position, leaving the Red Sox one swing short after Gasper's brief equalizer.