The teams traded runs in the third. Juan Soto's single scored Alvarez for New York, and Josh Jung answered with a double that brought home Danny Jansen. Texas went ahead in the fourth after Brandon Nimmo's error in right field allowed Carson Benge to score, but the lead lasted only until the bottom half ended. Elias Díaz and Wyatt Langford each lifted a sacrifice fly to put the Rangers ahead 3-2.
New York took control in the sixth. Alvarez's second double of the night scored Benge and Marcus Semien, then Luis Torrens followed with a sacrifice fly that brought Alvarez home. Benge added an insurance double in the seventh, scoring Brett Baty. Alvarez finished 2-for-5 with two doubles, two runs and two RBIs, while Benge went 2-for-4 with a double, a run and an RBI. Soto also had two hits and drove in a run.
Manaea allowed three hits and three runs, two earned, over six innings while striking out nine and walking two. The Mets bullpen closed the game with Nate Lavender, Dedniel Núñez and Kodai Senga each throwing a scoreless inning. Senga earned the save. Nathan Eovaldi took the loss after giving up three runs in one inning, and MacKenzie Gore allowed two earned runs over five innings for Texas.