San Diego had led since the first inning. Manny Machado walked with two outs, advanced on a wild pitch and scored on Ty France's single. France went 2 for 3 with two RBIs and supplied another run in the seventh, singling home Fernando Tatis Jr. to make it 3–1. Machado was thrown out at third on that play.
Milwaukee's errors had helped create the deficit. Luis Campusano scored in the fifth when Dustin Harris reached on a fielder's choice and Cooper Pratt made a throwing error. Tatis reached on David Hamilton's error in the seventh before France drove him home.
The Brewers answered both times. Yelich doubled and scored on Frelick's fifth-inning single. In the seventh, Mitchell scored when Hamilton reached on Jake Cronenworth's fielding error. Milwaukee still trailed 3–2 after Chourio grounded out to end that inning.
Both starters completed five innings. Michael King allowed one run on three hits, struck out six and did not walk a batter. Logan Henderson allowed two runs, one earned, on two hits with three walks and four strikeouts. Each threw 72 pitches and faced one batter in the sixth before being replaced.