Pratt broke the tie an inning later with a single to right off Tyler Wells, who took the loss. The Milwaukee crowd chanted "Coop" during the at-bat. Pratt finished 1 for 3 with a walk, and Frelick went 2 for 4.
The Brewers nearly added on in the eighth. Jackson Chourio singled and stole second and third, but he was thrown out at home on Contreras' grounder to short, and the call stood after Milwaukee challenged.
Henderson lasted three innings and allowed four runs, three earned. After that, Milwaukee's bullpen did not allow a run. JoJo Romero, Dustin May and DL Hall each threw a scoreless inning, and Abner Uribe got four outs and the win. Jonny DeLuca led off the ninth with a double to put the tying run on second, but Ashby struck out Victor Mesa Jr., got a groundout and struck out Yandy Diaz to end it.
Drew Rasmussen, facing his former team, gave up three runs in 3 2/3 innings for Tampa Bay. Contreras had two hits and is batting .395 this postseason, per ESPN's box score.
Milwaukee won Game 1 3-2 on Friday. The series now moves to Tampa Bay, and the Brewers need two more wins for their first championship.