Fisher compared the hire to technology startups "being created by kids" and said Smith's inexperience gives the club confidence he will try new things. "Some of them won't work, a lot of them will," Fisher said. Fisher said it was the first time in more than 70 years the franchise had gone outside the organization for the job, and he called hiring a general manager "a definite possibility." That spot has been empty since the A's parted ways with David Forst two months ago. Forst had been GM since 2015 and with the club since 2000.
The fan debate starts with the roster Smith inherits. The A's went 64-98, they are two years from a move to Las Vegas, and they played their second season at a Triple-A ballpark in West Sacramento, California, and their 5.51 ERA was second-worst in baseball, ahead of only Colorado's 5.59.
Smith thinks the pitching was "a little unlucky" on balls in play and said acquiring pitching is "something where you can be very opportunistic across the league." He inherits a young lineup core of Nick Kurtz, Jacob Wilson, Tyler Soderstrom and Lawrence Butler to go with veteran Brent Rooker.